Ancillary Justice
By Ann Leckie
Ancillary
Justice is the first novel by Ann Leckie. Ms. Leckie started writing
Ancillary Justice after the birth of her children as a way to stave
off boredom while being a homemaker. In fact she hammered out the
first draft for National Writing Month (Which is November folks!).
After attending a workshop under Octavia
Estelle Butler she hammered on it for 6 years until she produced a
novel that won the Hugo award, the Nebula award, the Arthur C Clarke
and the BSFA award... So you know all in all not bad for 6 years of
work. For comparison, Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone? Took
Rowling 7 years, there are worse ways to spend nearly a decade.
I've
been told by some folks that this book is the great liberal hype or
hope depending on whose talking. Honestly I don't see it. While
it's true the main culture in the book doesn't have gender... Let me
expand. The Radch don't have a concept of gender, it's completely
gone in their language. This doesn't make them a liberal society
however! Just a very different one. The Radch are human, but humans
thousands in the future in a very different environments then humans
live in now. In general I disapprove of layering our political
system on different times and places. The current
liberal/conservative divides are artifacts of our time and situation
and do not apply to Republican Rome or Imperial China for example and
they don't apply to Radch. That said, they are a militant,
aggressive, xenophobic and incredibly authoritarian power. I think
very few people would approve of the society presented in this book.
The fact that we have such a society and it is filled with
sympathetic and likable characters that you find yourself rooting for
is a testament to Ms. Leckie's writing abilities. Let me talk a
little about them.
Justice
of Toren One Esk, is a person, but she is not human. She is instead
an ancillary, a dead body implanted with cybernetics and inhabited by
an A.I. Calling her undead might be a stretch but we're not reaching
far here. These AI's until recently were one of the main weapons in
the Radch's war of eternal expansion. There are 3 kinds of ships.
The Swords, the large powerful ships. The Mercies, the smaller
warships. The Justices which are troop carriers, traditionally those
troops are ancillaries, lead by a small group of human officers.
Each of the ancillaries are organized into companies led by a small
group of human lieutenants. One Esk (as I will refer to her for the
rest of the review) was one such body. She used to be a part of the
Radch war machine, conquering planets in the name of the Radch as
part of a vast multi-body creature. Now she's alone outside of Radch
on a mission of revenge. She knows who to blame for her many, many
loses and she is going to make those responsible pay. One Esk is our
viewpoint character with the entire book being told through her
narration. She's an introspective and calm narrator without being
emotionless or so up her butt that you want to scream at her. She is
entirely relatable without becoming to human, basically staying just
inhuman enough that you are aware of seeing humanity through an
outsider's view. By human standards she's very cool and somewhat
distant. I don't mean that she's emotionless just that her
expression of emotion is very controlled and contained (with some
exceptions) and the emotions she does feel are not necessarily the
emotions a human being would feel. Despite being in a human body,
One Esk feels alien. In many ways she could be compared creature out
of nightmare. An eternal intelligence wrapped in a human body...
That was murdered for her use. Because the state she served found
that better then dealing with the problems of human soldiers. To be
fair to One Esk, she's not nightmarish but rather easy to respect and
even like. Which in a way feeds into the horror of the situation for
me but that's not the focus of the book.
Captain
Seivarden Vendaii is our second character, an officer from One Esk's
past. She was an Lt on Justice of Toren in the past... The long
distant past of a 1000 years, which is a long time for people even in
the far future. After being promoted to her own ship. Captain
Vendaii's ship was lost in battle. Captain Vendaii escaped the
destruction but laid in stasis for nearly a millennium and awoke to
found her perfect culture the best culture in the galaxy as far she
was concerned, altered and changed. She didn't have a good reaction
to it. One Esk finds her outside the Radch and for reasons she
doesn't understand decides to save Vendaii's life. The interesting
thing is that One Esk doesn't really like Captain Vendaii but for
reasons she can't explain often moves to protect and better Vendaii's
lot. I've pointed out relationships like this (Rabbit and Mbele from
Glowgems for Profit come to mind) in the past. Usually it's done to
humanize a character that audiences would have problems dealing with,
instead in this case Vendaii helps us to see the difference between
the past Radch and the present Radch. One Esk helps us understand
why the differences matter. The interactions between them also help
shine a deeper light into Radch culture itself which is massively
interesting to me.
Let me
address the Radch here because the culture is very much a character
as well as a background for the story. It's a totalitarian,
militant, classist, xenophobic and it was expansionist until recent
events... Events that pretty much set One Esk on her path. It's
also a very ritualized stable society with things changing so little
that a person from a thousand years ago can show up and still have a
good idea of what is going on and still talk to everyone. That's
bloody amazing when you consider that someone brought from 1000 years
ago to today wouldn't even be able to communicate effectively with us
in a lot of ways. Certainly not in English! The Radch culture is
divided into Houses that are constantly competing for wealth, power
and status. Much of this is conducted through the gathering of
clients for both personal and family status as well as attaining
prestigious posts and doing glorious deeds. Most of these deeds were
done in the annexations, where the Radch would show up in their
mighty AI run ships and declare that your world was now part of Radch
space, (you lucky dog you). By the way, if you try to fight we will
kill you and everyone you love. The Radch would co-opt the local
elites and bring them into the Rach culturally letting them become
clients of already established houses (in time they would create
their own Houses of course and so the game continues). The Radch
religion is a polytheist one, with gods being the focal points of
universal and moral forces that the Radch believe in. These gods are
not very anthropomorphized and the Radch deal with them mostly
through the throwing of omens and the giving of sacrifices. If
you're thinking to yourself that there are some Romans influences in
the mix, you would be right. But Ms. Leckie manages to create a
society with Roman inspirations that doesn't feel like Rome
transplanted into space. Just a culture that shares some
commonalities with Rome. Some differences are that positions are
given via the results of a series of tests call the Aptitudes (although it's suggested that for most of Radch history that family
ties played a deep role in your score). The lack of gender
(everyone is refereed to as She, One Esk has trouble even grasping
the concept of gender) and the very complex set of manners. Such as
an insistence on wearing gloves at all times in public (people
running around without gloves are practically treated as if they
showed up naked) as well as obsession for tea. Add in a rather post
modern disregard for Judeo-Christian sexual ethics as well and the
fact that you are always being observed by AI's no matter where you
go... This leaves you with a very alien society with complex rules
and mores. As you might guess I really, really like reading about
this culture. Not because I would want to live there (oh God No!)
but because it's so different and isn't just a re-skinned British
Kingdom/French Republic/United States of American In Space! Given my
Anthropologist training and enjoyment of learning about other
people's cultures, Ms. Leckie might as well be feeding me the world's
best Italian food laced with cocaine.
I also
have to praise Ms Leckie for her delivery. No long dry paragraphs of
characters musing over details they already know, no statements of
“As you know John,” nothing that clunky. Observations of Radch
culture are delivered to us in bite sized chunks by One Esk as
observations on events occurring or comparisons between the modern
era and Captain's Vendaii's time. All in all it was well done to
string out these observations and revelations through out the book
and make them part of the plot... Instead of just splattering giant
paragraphs of exposition everywhere (You Know Who You Who Are! YOU
KNOW!).
I
should mention the government before I turn to other topics. The
Radch are governed by one mind. One mind, with thousands upon
thousands of bodies. This group mind goes by Anaander Mianaai. She
is everywhere, all AI's report to her, since those AI's see almost
everything (including your vital signs by the way), Anaander Mianaai
sees almost everything. There are no checks or balances on Anaander
Mianaai, her word is law and nothing but her word is law. She
decides everything on every issue. She is ultimately responsible for
every decision and policy in Radch space. While the great Houses may
make their opinions and possibly, maybe sway her through good
argument or logic. In the end it is Anaander Mianaai that commands
and the Radch who obey. I would just like to say that Saron himself
didn't have dominion this absolute over Mordor. This is utterly and
completely terrifying on almost every level for me. I do have to
give Ms. Leckie points for not shying away from the logical
implications of this either. She does not try to soften the blow or
whitewash what this means. But this book also does ask an important
question about this style of government. A style of government that
has been the dream of a wide variety of people, on the right and left
wing. I won't spoil the question because frankly discovering it is
part of the joy of the story.
There
is some violence here but it's very rarefied. One Esk doesn't have
the same emotions or perceptions as we do towards violence or most
external stimuli. So while the violence is well described and
written... It lacks a visceral feel and is often the least gripping
parts of the book. I can't help but wonder if that's by design. Not
to get snobbish here, but often it seems that people who haven't
really experienced violence (and I don't mean a playground fight)
have trouble really getting the feel of it on the page. Of course
I'm sure that there are hundreds if not thousands of writers out
there who managed now that I've put such a statement on to paper.
Still if that's the case, I think Ms. Leckie found a good work around
by filtering through One Esk, making the violence ring considering
the alien mind it's being filtering though. We're also left with a
lot of questions of how Radch life actually works (I mean... How does
starting a family work if you don't have a concept of gender or
separate sexes? What's going on here?).
As you
might of guess, I'm going to state very strongly that Ancillary
Justice has earned it's rewards and it's acclaim. As for my part I
am giving Ancillary Justice by Ann Leckie an A. It's right up there
with Bridge of Birds or the Judging Eye for me and you haven't read
it. I must urge you to seek this book out and give it spin. I don't
think you'll be disappointed.
Next
week, Thieves Profit.
No comments:
Post a Comment